Books: Crossing the Line

Where is the line drawn between literature and fanfiction? Length? Character development? Readability? Publication? The physical presence of the author? As far as I can tell, the answer lies somewhere between the latter two.

Even though she’s been dead for quite some time now, Jane Austen’s books still excite quite a bit of admiration. So enamored with her characters (namely Elizabeth and Fitzwilliam Darcy) do some become that they take it upon themselves to continue the story. While this shouldn’t be surprising considering the web space devoted to alterations and continuations of living authors’ work (fanfiction.net, for example), it is still odd to come across a book on a shelf in a store that has somehow escaped the odious label of fanfiction.

Personally, I adore Jane Austen’s work. Pride and Prejudice has an especially dear place on my bookshelf (it’s one of the only books I own multiple copies of), so when I ran across multiple versions of what happened to the Darcys after their wedding, I found myself intrigued. Since that day, I’ve read four different versions.

Each one was unique, but overall they ranged in worth just as the online unpublished fanfictions did. Some were far more developed and intricate while others seeemed merely interested in what happened between the sheets of the Darcys’ marital bed. I even found myself wondering if one of the authors had ever even picked up the actual novel or had simply watched the condensed 2005 Kiera Knightly/Matthw Macfayden version. Overt references to the movie abounded and always in instances where the book was drastically different. It amazed me that something like this could cross the line between the unpublishable and the literary. But, then again, maybe it’s best to just take it as one more reminder that subjectivity rules here.

3 thoughts on “Books: Crossing the Line

  1. Sera Phyn

    Good point. I hadn't even considered those, but it's very true. I wonder how many books, when you really think about it, could be considered fanfiction in some way or another.

    Reply
  2. Emily Cross

    Well i wonder where is the line in regards to recent explosion of books which take a different view of the classics

    e.g. wicked.

    Really shouldn't that be classified as FF?

    Reply
  3. Angela

    You know, I never thought about this, but you're right–there are lots of books out there on the shelves that should rightly be called fan fiction. Is there a time limit after an author's death I wonder, that allows others to pick up the torch, kind of like how songs can be remade after a set period of time.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.